Builder Feedback and Armchair Critic Feedback

I’ve been both an armchair critic and builder over the years. I started out squarely as the former. However, I’ve come to appreciate how hard it is to actually build and ship something that adds value. So, I’ve attempted, over time, to be as constructive as possible in sharing my feedback on something someone else has built. And, a principle I’ve attempted to live by has been to only be very tough on something if I intend to spend my time and energy to help fix it.

The benefit of having been on all four sides of the table (both as a giver and receiver of both styles of criticism) is that I recognize the difference between builder feedback and armchair critic feedback. And, the one crucial difference is tone.

The armchair critic feedback takes refuge in sarcasm and typically adds some version of personal attack. So, if I had to take a swipe at myself this morning as an armchair critic, I’d say – “Seriously? Is this piece of drivel the best you can do as an employee of ____/graduate of ___?” It is hardly every constructive. And, even if you take the time to respond constructively, it is never going to be good enough.

Today’s post isn’t about how to deal with this type of feedback as that depends on the context.

But, it took me a long while to recognize this difference. And, recognizing it has been helpful in tailoring my response to it.

7 thoughts on “Builder Feedback and Armchair Critic Feedback

  1. I’ve tried to be a giver of constructive feedback. I’ve not considered the extra step of being part of the fix. So thanks, you’ve widened my horizons today.
    Tone is always a tough one, since it’s most important in the “ears” of the receiver, which is something I can’t control. I’m sometimes guilty of a perceived tone, that was not intended.
    What are your thoughts on improving tone?

    1. As I mentioned in my post, I am no expert for sure, Robin.

      I’ve come to see the wisdom in the idea that 9/10th of education is encouragement. Often, people know what needs to be fixed. And, our role is to help them along the way to continue shipping and making progress.

      I can’t say I live by this as yet. But, I hope to, in time. :)

      Not sure if that helps?


      http://www.ALearningaDay.com – *Never failure, only learning and never older, only better..*

      1. Thanks, Rohan.

        And 9/10th of encouragement is listening.

        Keep up the good work. I enjoy what you write, and even learn stuff from time to time :-)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s